While one is still on the creepier side of life, although nowhere near the hit the first art was, the other is pretty tame compared to the others, and just feels like most other Black kill spells
Either way, these are collectively the best tutors in Magic, and any deck interested in one is likely just as interested in the other
The downsides are once again pretty clear: for what it's worth, it's not a great FlickerFlicker target, but is also very susceptible to removal and doesn't do a whole lot on its own
I frequently mention that folks need to pack more nonbasic land hate, and this applies
On the plus side, Astrologians Planisphere is an artifact, which is important in the current Modern format
This orc dragon enters swinging with flying and haste, and it even has hexproof for safety on the turn it comes down